Skip to content

Why Swiss Watches Are Held Hostage Throughout Divorce Proceedings

Married Swiss watch collectors, beware: these treasured timepieces could cause cataclysmic custody battles in divorce court docket. As New York-based marital legislation lawyer Peter Bronstein associated, “I’ve a case now by which a spouse who was sad together with her state of affairs went to the household secure and eliminated a set of watches that clearly belonged to the husband and moved them to a vault field that is underneath her management earlier than she filed divorce papers.” Bronstein, who’s representing the husband, had a watch knowledgeable for his shopper’s aspect de él worth his assortment de él at over $600,000. The opposing aspect’s lawyer didn’t dispute the worth. “As this litigation has been pending for 3 years,” Bronstein mentioned, “my shopper’s watches have been held hostage for these three years.” Three years is certainly a very long time, and as Eugene Tutunikov, co–proprietor and CEO of the net pre-owned Swiss watch retailer Swiss Watch Expo, mused, “Time actually is cash, particularly when Swiss watches are held hostage.”

Among the many watches in his shopper’s assortment, Bronstein associated, “are some very helpful Rolexes and a few Patek Phillipes which are price a whole bunch of 1000’s of {dollars}. One Patek Phillipe watch, which is a diamond-encrusted Nautilus, has a very distinctive historical past because it had been given to my shopper by a head of state.”

Bronstein and his shopper await a choice by which the decide will ascribe the worth to the marital property, together with the watches. “If the decide concludes that the diamond Nautilus is a present,” Bronstein defined, “he’ll direct that it’s returned and the worth won’t be counted as a marital asset. The decide has the ability to find out who retains the watches themselves, however as soon as they’re pretty valued, it does not matter except there’s some main sentimental cause why one celebration needs a specific watch, or different comparable chattel.”

How and why did Swiss watches turn out to be common pawns in divorce proceedings? Jeweler and Swiss watch vendor Oliver Smith, proprietor of Oliver Smith Jeweler boutiques in Aspen, Colorado and Scottsdale, Arizona, has noticed a number of divorce-related horological horror tales. He ventures that divorce-related Watch Kidnappings could also be linked to the current rise in ladies sporting giant Swiss luxurious watches as trend statements. “Just a few years in the past,” Smith recalled, “ladies began sporting bigger watches. The posh watch trade was sluggish to react and begin designing bigger watches for girls, so many started borrowing their husband’s watch, as that was the popular measurement for the modern.”

Having offered such manufacturers as Rolex, Parmigiani Fleurier, Cartier and Panerai for the previous 30 years, Smith additionally manages the Panerai boutique in Aspen, Colorado. Smith mentioned that in his expertise of him, “Many males by no means come clear to their partner concerning the true price of the watch they’re sporting. They inform them, ‘Oh this was solely a pair thousand’ when in actual fact it is a $50,000 timepiece. When a husband sees his spouse sporting their watch de ella with a tennis bracelet and scratching all of it up as a result of they throw it right into a change purse after they’re on the fitness center, they get nervous.” When husbands see that their wives “have zero regard for what’s a extremely helpful watch, a dilemma develops.” Eventualities like these “gave rise to ladies understanding the true worth of those watches” previous a divorce.

It is price noting that estranged husbands are additionally identified to grab Swiss watches that they’ve given to their wives as items throughout explosive divorce proceedings. In an internationally reported case, a custody battle over a $35,000 Rolex watch almost quashed a multimillion-dollar divorce settlement between Pink Floyd musician-songwriter Roger Waters and his estranged fourth spouse, filmmaker Laurie Durning. In response to the New York Put up, Throughout, who was represented by the above-quoted lawyer Peter Bronstein, declared in Manhattan Supreme Court docket, “I would like my watch. That is all,” mere minutes earlier than she was set to signal the papers that will finalize her divorce from the rock’n’roll legend.

Because the New York Put up reported, “What a–gap you’re,” Throughout instructed Waters because the decide took the bench. Additionally for the post, Waters responded to the insult by elevating his palms up by his shoulders and shrugging as if to say, “No matter.” The couple had a prenuptial settlement that was described as “beneficiant” to Throughout, in keeping with the publish‘s supply. Whereas particulars stay confidential, Waters is reportedly price no less than $100 million {dollars}. With lyrics written completely by Waters, Pink Floyd’s The Darkish Facet of the Moon is without doubt one of the most profitable rock albums of all time. Having spent 736 consecutive weeks (that is 14.1151 years) on the Billboard 200 chart, the album offered over 40 million copies worldwide. Waters left Pink Floyd in 1985 however has been performing the band’s classics like “Darkish Facet of the Moon” and “The Wall” on solo excursions since then.)

The battle continued when Waters’ lawyer, Robert Dobrish, instructed Throughout, “It is your watch. Decide it up on the retailer.” Throughout instructed Justice Lori Sattler that she had tried to retrieve her gold Daytona Rolex from the approved Rolex restore facility, however workers refused to launch it as a result of the timepiece was being held within the title of Waters’ assistant. The publish He additionally recorded that Duringning instructed the decide, “Once I handed his private stuff again to him, he ought to have handed me the watch.” Justice Sattler responded by ordering each events to signal a second settlement, along with their divorce settlement, stating that the watch belonged to Throughout.

In response to Bronstein, there are some essential steps that watch collectors, and those that obtain watches as items, can take to assist stop divorce-related horological horror tales. First on the checklist entails getting a licensed appraiser to appraise the watch or assortment. “Watches needs to be appraised. They might develop into an necessary asset of the marital property. A watch assortment, like all collectible, can have actual worth,” Bronstein famous. “The appraiser, the place doable, ought to personally look at each bit.” Tutunikov agreed with Bronstein, and added, “In the event you self-purchase a watch or a chunk of knickknack, at all times maintain the receipts as proof of your buy.”

As a result of the authorized definition of marital property differs from state to state, “It is a good suggestion for watch collectors to search out out what the authorized definition of marital property is of their state so as to finest safeguard their watch collections,” Tutunikov steered. “Within the state of New York,” Bronstein provided for example, “Marital property is property that’s acquired through the marriage, except it’s inherited or gifted to a partner by a 3rd celebration.” As a result of watches will not be at all times bought, an inherited watch wouldn’t be marital property in New York state.”

With regards to watches given as items, whereas Bronstein’s shopper could have acquired his diamond-encrusted Patek Phillipe Nautilus as a present, how does one doc such a present? “The reply is, any means you may!” Bronstein mentioned with amusing. “The whole lot will be useful. {A photograph}, an e mail or testimony of both the donor or the recipient, or each. The circumstances can be related, such because the date, which may be adjoining to an necessary occasion or vacation.”

Attempt to maintain any supporting proof of a watch given as a present, Bronstein suggested. There could also be a card that accompanied the gifted watch that reads, “Blissful Anniversary”, or “Congratulations on a job effectively executed.” Bronstein added that,A watch given at a retirement dinner for years of service to the corporate could also be a marital asset identical to the annual bonus. It is not wage, however it’s associated to the companies offered.” Bronstein requested, “Was the watch in that instance given to a husband as a present for companies? Or was it given to him by somebody out of deep appreciation for a friendship? That may be a query of proof.”

Additional complicating issues is the truth that within the appraisal enterprise, there are a number of various kinds of worth. The bottom is money property worth, or what a keen purchaser and vendor will commerce a chunk for money worth. As Smith noticed, “This could create a giant value differential between a watch’s substitute worth and its property worth. The very fact is, he asserted, “Watches are insured at substitute worth, however they’re traded at property worth. So you may see the battle coming to determine an agreed upon worth of a watch, or of a set, throughout a divorce.”

In abstract, getting your watch or assortment appraised, preserving correct gross sales slips or playing cards that accompanied a gifted watch, and telling your partner the true price of your Swiss watch may doubtlessly prevent horological heartache, in addition to authorized charges. As Tutunikov mused, “The time to guard your watches from Destiny is now.” Must you come by means of a divorce sustaining possession of a watch given to you by your ex, Tutunikov associated, “You may at all times promote it, must you want or need to. Lots of our clients promote as a result of it both reminds them of their ex, or their new associate prefers that they off load a extremely seen, day by day reminder of that previous relationship. As he defined, “Many occasions we have had women and men are available in with a watch to promote that got here from an ex, solely to appreciate that they’ll miss sporting a luxurious timepiece. So,” he continued, “they commerce their outdated watch in and acquire the funds to improve to a brand new one which symbolizes the intense future forward. There’s nothing like a brand new watch to make you reside within the second, treasuring your time,” Tutunikov mentioned.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *