Skip to content

State says typo led to homicide suspect’s launch from dedication

The state Division of Psychological Well being and Habit Providers stated a clerical error led to a misunderstanding in regards to the launch from civil dedication of James Armstrong, the North Stonington man charged with homicide within the 2017 taking pictures dying of his cousin.

Armstrong, 35, who’s accused of killing 31-year-old Ralph Sebastian Sidberry at Sidberry’s house on the Japanese Pequot Tribal Nation reservation, has up to now prevented prison prosecution and as a substitute is civilly dedicated as a psychiatric affected person at Whiting Forensic Hospital in Middletown.

Earlier this month, throughout his often scheduled competence listening to in New London Superior Court docket, the courtroom was knowledgeable that not solely was Armstrong being thought of for launch into supportive housing by the Middletown Probate Court docket that overlooks his dedication case, however that his civil dedication had ended .

His supposed launch from civil dedication was an error, in line with a Jan. 11 letter to New London Superior Court docket Choose Hillary Strackbein from Dr. Lori L. Hauser, the supervising forensic psychologist at Whiting.

The show courtroom, following a Dec. 2 listening to, discovered “by clear and convincing proof that (Armstrong) has psychiatric disabilities and is harmful to himself or herself or others or gravely disabled,” Hauser wrote.

The misunderstanding got here from a Probate Court docket doc that learn: “THE COURT DOES NOT FIND by clear and convincing proof…” that Armstrong was a hazard to himself and others, Hauser wrote.

The error has since been corrected and Armstrong stays a affected person at Whiting, which homes individuals held for courtroom competence restoration and for people discovered not responsible of against the law for cause of psychological illness or defect.

Middletown Probate Choose Joseph D. Marino discovered in the course of the Dec. 2 listening to that “much less restrictive placement just isn’t out there,” for Armstrong, courtroom paperwork present. Hauser stated in her Jan. 11 letter, acquired by The Day on Monday, that Armstrong has been at Whiting ever since he was dedicated in 2018.

However courtroom testimony from a member of the staff that carried out Armstrong’s newest evaluation revealed Armstrong, who walked into courtroom with none obvious safety, is in a much less restrictive program on the hospital and being thought of for a voluntary program exterior of Whiting. His attainable launch from Whiting has Sidberry’s family and friends and Superior Court docket officers involved.

Assistant State’s Lawyer Theresa Anne Ferryman has referred to as for an unbiased analysis of Armstrong in response to the newest report that once more exhibits Armstrong to be not competent to face trial and never capable of be restored to competence, a designation that bars prison prosecution.

Armstrong can’t be prosecuted for homicide if he’s discovered not competent, or unable to grasp the proceedings and help in his personal protection.

On Monday, Ferryman stated little has modified from the state’s perspective with information of the clerical error.

“The state’s considerations about public security and Mr. Armstrong’s standing persist,” Ferryman stated.

Armstrong suffers from schizophrenia and character dysfunction. Police stated Armstrong, previous to the taking pictures, claimed Sidberry was spreading HIV to fellow tribal members, although exams confirmed Sidberry didn’t have the virus. Sidberry was married to a younger daughter and a pregnant spouse.

State Sen. Heather Somer, R-Groton, has launched laws which she stated will present safeguards for victims and their households. The laws requires a evaluate and revision of state legal guidelines regarding jurisdiction to face trial and launch of an individual from civil dedication, particularly when a defendant is charged with the dying of one other particular person. It additionally contains provisions that might notify victims if a defendant is to be launched from dedication and a evaluate of the authority to order unbiased competence evaluations.

Somers was in courtroom earlier this month with Sidberry’s household when information of his attainable launch from Whiting was introduced. She additionally heard the information, now identified to be misguided, of Armstrong’s launch from civil dedication.

“This case ought to ring alarm bells throughout our prison justice system and clearly we have to make reforms,” Somers stated in an announcement. “The system is actually permitting an arrested assassin to go free, and that’s merely unfathomable. This can be a public security safety problem, a psychological well being problem, in addition to a sufferer’s rights problem. Modifications should be made. Loopholes in our legal guidelines should be closed.”

The invoice, generally known as Senate Invoice 888, awaits a public listening to within the legislature’s Judiciary Committee, Somers stated.

Sidberry’s mom, former Japanese Pequot Tribal Chairwoman Katherine Sebastian Dring, stated she has filed a criticism towards the state for a violation of her rights of due course of and equal safety below the 14th Modification, citing state statute 54-56d concerning competence to face trial.

“This can be a very troublesome combat for justice for my son in a transparent minimize case of premeditated homicide,” Sebastian Dring stated in an e mail.

Armstrong is due again in New London Superior Court docket on March 1 the place the Ferryman stated she hopes to acquire extra details about Armstrong’s standing. One other evaluate of his civil dedication is scheduled in Middletown Superior Court docket on April 14. Probate Court docket proceedings are usually not public.

g.smith@theday.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *